Bad comm! No biscuit!
Feb. 8th, 2008 03:58 amFor any members (present or future) of
debunkingwhite -
stoneself has posted a great article on the purpose of the community:
What I Think debunkingwhite Is About.
Sample quote:
debunkingwhite is about debunking white.
[...]
--
Related thought: some of the things people say in
debunkingwhite, ostensibly to demonstrate their willingness to engage the ideas and the discussion, are so goddamned obnoxious!
I mean really, INTENSELY butt-licking obnoxious. SCREAMING for praise and pats on the head. For example:
*shuts up and goes back to learning*
...Okay?! Do you want your Good White Person sash badge now? Jesus. WTF.
And I keep mentally debating. Should I say something when I see this nonsense? Am I sure it's always as obsequious as it sounds, or am I making excuses for people if I think perhaps in an effort to sound like they were listening, they worded it badly?
Would it actually help things along to say something, or is that just an inevitable stage that every white anti-racist moves through? Is there a way to point it out without having someone who is tentatively becoming more involved in the discussion decide the community is "mean" and "jumps on everything" and withdraw?
GAH.
(And oh my GOD, I've had this stupid headache for HOURS now, and it won't GO AWAY. *snarls*)
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-community.gif)
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
What I Think debunkingwhite Is About.
Sample quote:
debunkingwhite is about debunking white.
[...]
- not about highlighting white anti-racism.
debunkingwhite is not the place for white people looking for cookies. no one here is going to hand you a cookie for your "good" anti-racist behavior. and again, just because debunkingwhite isn't about rewarding people for anti-racist behavior, doesn't mean the people here don't see your anti-racist behavior.
if you really need a group for that, i suggest you go create cookies4antiracistwhites.
--
Related thought: some of the things people say in
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-community.gif)
I mean really, INTENSELY butt-licking obnoxious. SCREAMING for praise and pats on the head. For example:
*shuts up and goes back to learning*
...Okay?! Do you want your Good White Person sash badge now? Jesus. WTF.
And I keep mentally debating. Should I say something when I see this nonsense? Am I sure it's always as obsequious as it sounds, or am I making excuses for people if I think perhaps in an effort to sound like they were listening, they worded it badly?
Would it actually help things along to say something, or is that just an inevitable stage that every white anti-racist moves through? Is there a way to point it out without having someone who is tentatively becoming more involved in the discussion decide the community is "mean" and "jumps on everything" and withdraw?
GAH.
(And oh my GOD, I've had this stupid headache for HOURS now, and it won't GO AWAY. *snarls*)